The strength they couldn’t see

Some years ago I worked with a long-standing Nelson engineering firm. Alongside another consultant, I helped the team work out where to put their energy after they lost a major client. They were about to start a rebrand and modernisation, and wanted to make sure they weren’t missing any blind spots.

It’s still the clearest example I have of something I see in almost every business. The thing that makes you valuable to customers is often the thing you’ve stopped noticing.

A big loss, and a good question

Losing a major client is hard for any business. It’s also a moment that makes you look up from the day to day.

The firm did a lot of things well, across marine, on-site and specialist work. The question was where to focus next. Rather than chase brand new markets, the owners wanted to start with the customers they already had, and understand them properly.

That’s a good instinct. Your existing customers already know why they chose you. Most businesses just never ask them.

Three questions

We started with three simple questions:

  1. Who do we most enjoy working for?

  2. Who pays us the most?

  3. Who tells other people about us?

We worked with the senior leadership team, because they held the relationships with these companies. We asked which clients they most enjoyed working for, then checked their answers against the revenue figures. A client your team enjoys working with is usually one that stays.

A clear group came out of it: big operations like forestry plants, manufacturers and ship repair yards. Busy sites with serious engineering needs.

Then we talked to them

Next I interviewed those customers. Proper conversations, with several people at each site, because on a big operation the person who signs off the work isn’t the only one who sees it.

One theme came through in every interview. The crew were professional, and they took health and safety seriously. Customers said it set them apart from other engineering firms, at a time when health and safety was becoming a much bigger focus across the industry.

The team had no idea. To them it was just how they worked. Nobody had ever told them it was a reason customers kept calling.

They printed the customer quotes and put them up on the workshop walls. It wasn’t a marketing exercise by then. It was the team seeing, in their customers’ own words, what they were good at.

Peter Perfect

One afternoon we sat down with the lead engineer, the key account manager, the managing director and the sales team, and built a picture of their ideal customer. We gave him a name: Peter Perfect.

I’m sure some of the room thought it was a bit soft. Persona building can sound like marketing talk when you work with steel all day.

About eighteen months later I caught up with the CEO. New branded vehicles were on the road around Nelson. He told me he’d thought Peter Perfect was a bit of a laugh at the time. But their best new customers were “bang on” the profile we’d built that afternoon.

What I took from it

I’ve since seen the same pattern in a polytechnic, an online education company and a software business. Three views of a business sit side by side: the owner’s, the team’s and the customers’. They rarely match, and nobody notices the gap until someone asks.

The firm didn’t need to become something new. It needed to see clearly what it already was, and point that at the right customers.

That’s worth knowing before any big move. A new market, a new service, a rebrand or a key hire all go better when you know why your best customers chose you in the first place.

Try it yourself

Before your next big decision, set aside an hour for these:

  • Who does your team most enjoy working for? Ask the leaders who hold your client relationships. They know which clients the team likes turning up for.

  • Who pays you the most? Count how long they stay and what they cost to serve, not just the size of the invoice.

  • Who sends you new business without being asked?

Then pick three of those customers and call them. Ask why they chose you, what they’d miss if you weren’t there, and what they tell other people about you.

Write down their exact words. There’s a good chance you’ll hear about something your team does every day without a second thought.